When Kathleen saw how much health insurance would cost her and her husband next year, the 61-year-old Indiana real estate agent took to Facebook to ask friends and followers for advice: Did anyone have ideas for a more affordable option?
Soon, she was overwhelmed with messages and comments from other people in Indiana and around the country who were also facing skyrocketing insurance costs.
“Everyone is in the same boat. If you’re self-employed, it’s like they’re slapping you on the hand — truly,” she said.
FPI News agreed to identify Kathleen by her first name so she could speak freely about her family’s finances.
Kathleen and her husband, who both run their own businesses, purchase insurance through the federal Health Insurance Marketplace. If they continue on the same plan, their premiums could rise by about a third next year — reaching $2,800 a month. That’s double the amount they paid just two years ago, when marketplace prices were lower and the government offered more generous subsidies. They also pay for their son’s insurance, which has also had a substantial increase.
The couple said at the same time insurance premiums are rising, the out-of-pocket maximum and copays on their current plan will go up.
The price of insurance on the marketplace, which was created by the Affordable Care Act or Obamacare, will spike for the second year in a row across the country. In Indiana, the average approved rate increase for insurers on the marketplace is more than 17% in 2027.
“My husband and I have worked our butts off for the last 30 years building our businesses,” Kathleen said. “We feel like we’re being penalized.”
As the couple faces the prospect of paying nearly $34,000 for insurance next year, they are considering dropping their marketplace insurance.
“We have to take time from our jobs where we are making our income to pay the insurance to go out and try to figure all this out,” Kathleen said. “It’s ridiculous.”
Consumers can purchase lower-cost policies that do not comply with ACA requirements — such as providing coverage for pre-existing conditions and preventive care — from brokers or insurance companies. But those policies leave people vulnerable to huge bills if they face a crisis.
Why prices are higher
A lot of factors have caused increasing premiums on the marketplace. Rising prices for all sorts of medical treatment, from hospital visits to prescriptions, are an issue. At the same time, the ACA Marketplace has unique pressures.
The marketplace offers income-based subsidies to help people afford health insurance. During the pandemic, those subsidies were expanded to be more generous and cover more people. But the Republican-led Congress let those expanded credits expire last year. Most enrollees with a subsidy lost at least some help — and the average amount people were paying each month after tax credits rose by 58%, according to KFF, which provides nonpartisan information on healthcare.
As costs have risen, enrollment has fallen. A KFF analysis estimated that enrollment in the individual insurance market — including marketplace and off-marketplace plans — fell by more than 4.6 million people nationwide.
Indiana’s marketplace has had one of the steepest enrollment declines in the country, with a drop of about 28% this year, according to KFF.
When relatively healthy people drop insurance, the pool of enrollees becomes sicker and older, because those Americans are less willing to go without. Insurance companies raise prices to cover the higher medical costs for those that remain.
When shopping around doesn’t help
In Indianapolis, Bill has seen the sudden increase in marketplace prices while shopping for insurance for his 61-year-old wife, who runs a small business. FPI News agreed to refer to Bill by his first name because his wife is concerned that speaking publicly will harm her business.
“We have changed companies almost every year,” said Bill, a retired accountant who is covered by Medicare. “Whatever company we had when the increase was unacceptable, we would go on the website and change to another company.”
For 2027, they had fewer options. In a number of states, including Indiana, insurers are pulling out of the marketplace.
Bill said his wife’s premiums rose by 11% this year, and next year they will go up another 19%. They chose the cheapest plan, he said, but it will still cost more than $1,000 a month.
They don’t feel like they have a choice.
“You just don’t want to show up at a hospital without insurance,” he said.
When you’re forced to pick a new insurer
Breezy Peyton, a 45-year-old musician in southern Indiana, and her husband play together in the Reverend Peyton’s Big Damn Band and have a marketplace plan through CareSource this year. But the insurer, CareSource, is pulling out of Indiana next year.
The marketplace recommended a plan that would cost more than $1,200 a month after the subsidy. The plan has a $14,000 deductible. Peyton said it would not pay toward prescriptions until the deductible was met.
“Most of my friends, they’re just not buying health insurance now. They’re just letting it ride, and I don’t blame them,” said Peyton, who mentioned that she has given to dozens of healthcare-related crowdfunding campaigns.

“But I watched my father-in-law, who couldn’t pay for his medicine, skip his insulin and try to stretch it longer, completely ruin his kidneys, end up on dialysis and die from it,” Peyton said. “And I don’t want that future for my husband.”
Changing to a new insurer will have a big downside: Fewer than half the doctors she and her husband see now would be in-network. That means they would need to find different specialists, who could have long waits for new patients, she said. In the end, they may go months without care.
“I feel very helpless,” Peyton said.
What you can do
If you’re buying Affordable Care Act insurance, buy only on healthcare.gov. This will ensure the plan is ACA-compliant, with protections like coverage for pre-existing conditions and preventive care.
If you find healthcare.gov confusing, you can ask to talk to an assister. These are trained professionals, paid to give unbiased advice.
Brokers can be helpful, but brokers are likely to get paid commission on what they sell, meaning that the plan they sell you might be the best for them (higher commission) but maybe not the best for you (worse coverage).
If someone offers you a plan that seems too good to be true — better prices and/or better or equal coverage — stop and make sure you are dealing with someone who is selling ACA-compliant plans. There are a lot of “skinny” or “short-term” plans out there that are not regulated as ACA plans are. You might find out that your insurance won’t cover even the basics.
Don’t click on the first link that comes up on your Google search for “healthcare.gov indiana” or any other general search — make sure you are on healthcare.gov. There are scammers who buy higher placement on Google search.
Consider “gold” plans too. Sometimes advisors will suggest the benchmark “second cheapest silver,” but in some cases, gold plans can be cheaper. (Gold plans can have lower deductibles and better benefits.)
Fill out all the forms with your best estimate of your income for the coming year. You may think you don’t qualify, but the federal poverty level has risen rapidly in high-inflation years. For a family of four, 400% of the federal poverty level is set at an income of $132,000, so if you are at or below that, you’re likely to qualify for an ACA subsidy. See the tables here. This information is used in the subsidy calculators.
Keep careful records of what you signed up for and when, and at what price. If you talk to anyone on the phone, keep a record of when and who and what number.
Don’t automatically renew what you had last year. Plans change, sometimes dramatically.
Reporter Jeanne Pinder contributed to this story through a collaboration with Main Street Media Cooperative, which offers the services of experienced journalists to help local outlets report about the effect of changes in
Washington on their communities. Pinder is founder and CEO of ClearHealthCosts.com.
FPI News, a nonprofit newsroom, is funded through grants and donations from individuals, foundations and organizations. Sign up for our free newsletter.



